Best Construction Methods for Flat Packs: 

Butt and Screw vs Mortise and Tenon vs Dowel vs Confirmat Screw

When it comes to flat pack cabinetry, the joinery method you choose doesn’t just influence the final product—it has a direct impact on your CNC runtime, tool wear, labour requirements, and ultimately your cost of goods sold (COGS). For manufacturers selling cut-to-size cabinetry (AKA flat packs), selecting the right construction method is a balancing act between efficiency, strength, ease of assembly, and customer satisfaction.

In this article, we take a detailed look at four of the most common flat pack construction techniques—butt and screw, mortise and tenon, dowel, and confirmat screw—exploring their advantages, disadvantages, and best use cases.

Butt and Screw: Fastest Off the CNC

Overview: This is the most basic form of cabinet construction. It involves simply butting one panel against another at a right angle and securing them with screws. There’s no special shaping or alignment features—just put them together and punch in a screw.

Pros:

  • Fastest CNC processing: Because there’s no need for complex toolpaths, extra machining, or secondary processes, this is the quickest method to produce on a CNC machine. It’s ideal for fast turnarounds.
  • Minimal tool wear: Simple straight cuts and hole drilling mean your router bits and tools experience less wear, extending their lifespan and reducing tooling costs.
  • Low setup requirements: Great for shops that want to move volume quickly without investing in extra equipment.

Cons:

  • High assembly error risk: Without alignment features, it’s easy for the person assembling the cabinet to misalign panels. This can result in boxes that aren’t square, reduced strength, or screws bursting through the panel edges.
  • Low structural strength: This method relies solely on the screw’s holding power in MDF or particleboard, which is not always reliable, especially over time or with heavy loads. At a minimum, it’s advisable to additionally glue components before screwing, or pin them with a nail gun.
  • Aesthetics and perception: Exposed screw heads can reduce the perceived quality of the finished product unless additional steps are taken to hide or plug them.

Best For: flat pack ranges where speed, price and ‘no frills’ are perhaps more important than longevity or finish quality.

Mortise and Tenon: Premium But Pricey

Overview: A traditional woodworking joint, mortise and tenon involves inserting a protruding “tenon” on one piece into a matching “mortise” cavity on another. While incredibly strong and refined, it demands precise CNC routing and attention to material thickness.

Pros:

  • Exceptional strength: The tenon provides a mechanical interlock, giving the joint significant holding power. It’s ideal for load-bearing components or cabinetry expected to last decades.
  • Professional appearance: The joint is internal, with fewer required screws or fasteners. This gives a clean, high-end look.

Cons:

  • Time-intensive CNC operations: This method significantly increases CNC machining time. Each joint requires multiple toolpaths and careful cutting, often at slower speeds to ensure clean finishes.
  • Increased tool wear: More intricate cutting leads to greater wear and tear on your router bits and machinery, increasing maintenance costs.
  • Material inconsistency issues: MDF and particleboard can vary in thickness between batches. Even a 0.2mm difference can affect the snugness of the fit, leading to loose joints or gaps—requiring frequent updates to software and machine settings.

Best For: Premium, showroom-quality cabinetry where strength, precision, and aesthetics justify the higher cost and longer production time.

Dowel: Hidden Strength with CNC Precision

Overview: Dowels are cylindrical wooden or plastic pins inserted into corresponding holes on mating parts. The joints are usually glued and rely on tight tolerances to stay aligned and strong.

Pros:

  • Excellent alignment: Because dowels are inserted into pre-drilled holes, they act as guides that help panels align perfectly during assembly. This significantly reduces the risk of human error.
  • Clean, concealed finish: There are no visible screws or fasteners, giving a more polished look that consumers appreciate.
  • Strong and repeatable: When set up properly on a CNC, dowel holes can be drilled with incredible precision, ensuring a snug fit every time.

Cons:

  • Secondary drilling required: Unlike butt joints, dowels need holes drilled into the ends and faces of panels. This often involves extra passes through CNC or dedicated drilling equipment, increasing handling and production time.
  • Glue adds complexity: If the dowels are glued during assembly, it requires clean conditions and adds drying time, which can complicate flat pack logistics.

Best For: Mid- to high-end cabinetry that needs to be easy to assemble, structurally sound, and visually appealing.

Confirmat Screw: The Flat Pack Specialist

Overview: Confirmat screws are specifically designed for use in particleboard and MDF. They have a larger thread and are typically installed with a special bit that creates a clean, wide pilot hole.

Pros:

  • Very strong in manufactured boards: Unlike standard screws, confirmat screws bite deeply and hold securely in lower-density materials.
  • Fast and forgiving assembly: Great for DIY customers—parts self-align better, and joints are more tolerant of minor inaccuracies.
  • Disassemblable: Cabinets can be taken apart and reassembled without losing integrity, which is appealing in modular or office furniture.

Cons:

  • Secondary machining needed: As with dowels, confirmat joints require holes drilled on the ends of panels, adding steps and handling in production.
  • Visible hardware: The screw heads are exposed unless plugged, which may not suit more design-conscious applications.
  • Tooling required: Assembly requires a specific confirmat bit, which not all end users may have.

Best For: Flat pack systems where durability, ease of assembly, and cost-effective production are top priorities—especially in DIY or relocatable furniture markets.

Choosing the Right Fit for Your Workflow

Joinery Method

CNC Time

Assembly Risk

Tool Wear

Strength

Assembly Speed

DIY-Friendly

Butt & Screw

⭐ ⭐ Fast

⚠️ High

⭐ Low

⚠️ OK

⭐ Medium

⭐ OK

Mortise & Tenon

🔴 High

⭐ Low

🔴 High

⭐⭐ Strong

⭐ Medium

⭐⭐ Yes

Dowell

⚠️ Medium

⭐ Low

⚠️ Medium

⭐⭐ Strong

⭐⭐ Fast

⭐⭐ Yes

Confirmat Screw

⚠️ Medium

⭐ Low

⚠️ Medium

⭐⭐ Strong

⭐⭐ Fast

⭐⭐ Yes

Choosing the Right Fit for Your Workflow

Butt & Screw

CNC Time

⭐ ⭐ Fast

Assembly Risk

⚠️ High

Tool Wear

⭐ Low

Strength

⚠️ OK

Assembly Speed

⭐ Medium

DIY-Friendly

⭐ OK

Mortise & Tenon

CNC Time

🔴 High

Assembly Risk

⭐ Low

Tool Wear

🔴 High

Strength

⭐⭐ Strong

Assembly Speed

⭐ Medium

DIY-Friendly

⭐⭐ Yes

Dowell

CNC Time

⚠️ Medium

Assembly Risk

⭐ Low

Tool Wear

⚠️ Medium

Strength

⭐⭐ Strong

Assembly Speed

⭐ ⭐ Fast

DIY-Friendly

⭐⭐ Yes

Confirmat Screw

CNC Time

⚠️ Medium

Assembly Risk

⭐ Low

Tool Wear

⚠️ Medium

Strength

⭐⭐ Strong

Assembly Speed

⭐ ⭐ Fast

DIY-Friendly

⭐⭐ Yes

Final Thoughts

Each construction method serves a purpose. For manufacturers offering flat packs, the key is to align joinery choices with your market positioning, production capabilities, and cost structure. Butt and screw works for high-speed, budget production. Mortise and tenon is ideal for bespoke, high-value cabinetry. Dowel and confirmat strike a balance between strength, speed, and customer satisfaction.